Slumber Bear vs Sleep Sheep: Which Will Sooth Your Little One to Sleep?

Both the Slumber Bear and Sleep Sheep have been ranked among the top baby soothers year after year. Parents have come to trust them as tried and true audio pacifiers for their little ones. Both companies behind these cuddly soothers offer different variations of their original model, but for our purposes we are going to look strictly at the original two products from Cloud B and Prince Lionheart. Let’s get started and see how they rank up.

Prince Lionheart SlumberBear Review

This product has been around for upwards of 27 years and was developed originally by a OB/GYN. Let’s take a look at its stats.

Price: 

Warranty: 1-year limited warranty

Pros:

• Invented by a doctor
• Used in hospitals
• Plays authentic intrauterine sounds
• Adjustable volume levels
• Bear can attach to the side of the crib via Velcro paws
• 5-minute playback
• Standby mode with automatic reactivation from sound or motion
• Removable sound machine that can be attached to cribs
• Comes with a “Silkie” lovey blanket for baby which can take on mom’s scent
• Battery operated and included
• Easily portable
• Small Size
• Plushy and Cuddly

Cons:

• The 5-minute playback is often too short to lull babies to sleep
• The sensitivity of the reactivation mode is sometimes too low to pick up on baby’s sounds and movements
• The constant nature of the soother activating off and on all night means the batteries drain rapidly
• The sounds can contain static, remember the sounds are an actual recording of intrauterine sounds from within an expectant mother
• While it is plush, it is not nearly as soft as it might appear. Still adorable, however.
• The sound coming on during reactivation can sometimes startle babies.
• No setting for continuous sound

Buy Slumber Bear on Amazon

Cloud B Sleep Sheep Review

This product might seem like a relative newcomer compared to the previous one, but it has the industry awards to prove it belongs right alongside of any audio soother for babies. Let’s talk about its stats.

Price: 

Warranty: 180-day warranty on plush components and 1-year warranty on electronic components

Pros:

• 8 soothing sounds and melodies
• Adjustable volume levels
• Two sleep-timer options: 23 and 45 minutes with auto-shut off
• Sheep can attach to the sides of the crib via Velcro tabs
• Removable sound machine that can be attached to cribs
• Exceeds safety standards
• Comes with a storybook and adoption certificate
• Battery operated and included
• Easily portable
• Small Size
• Plush and cuddly

Cons:

• Screws on the battery case are tiny and sometimes hard to remove
• Sounds are not that realistic
• Sounds can sometimes be too quiet
• No setting for continuous sound

Buy Sleep Sheep on Amazon

Final Verdict: Sleep Sheep or SlumberBear

They both have their uses and accolades. If you want a soother that will turn on automatically for your child during the night without you having to reset it, then you might want the Slumber Bear. If you are interested in more of a traditional white noise machine for the nursery, then the Cloud B Sleep Sheepwill be your best bet. When you look at their overall specs, it might be daunting to make a comparison between the two but if we were forced to choose between these two soothers then our clear winner would be the Cloud B Sleep Sheep. We love the options with it and it comes with all the bells and whistles that we would want from an audio soother for our own baby.